Dairy Farms & Creameries near Penn Yan, NY
4 dairy farms & creameries within about 30 miles of Penn Yan — Crosswinds Farm & Creamery, Shtayburne Farm Creamery and Lively Run Goat Dairy, and more. Farmstead milk, cheese, and raw-milk herd shares.
Crosswinds Farm & Creamery
14.5 miRock Stream
Shtayburne Farm Creamery
15.8 miShtayburne Farm Creamery is a farmstead cheese maker in Rock Stream, New York, in the Finger Lakes, not Pennsylvania as the listing shows. The dairy makes cheddar and fresh squeaky cheese curds from its own herd. Details online are thin here, so confirm the farm store hours and current cheese selection before driving out.
Lively Run Goat Dairy
17.5 miLively Run is one of the country's longest-running commercial goat dairies, making cheese in Interlaken since 1982. Steve and Susanne Messmer bought the farm in 1995 and kept producing goat, cow, and sheep cheeses with milk from Finger Lakes partner farms. Their Cayuga Blue, Finger Lakes Gold, and Feta have all won American Cheese Society awards. The farm store, tastings, and baby-goat feedings run May through October.
Sunset View Creamery
27.7 miOdessa
Sunset View Creamery is a family dairy on County Road 14 in Odessa, in the Finger Lakes' Schuyler County, making artisan cheeses, raw milk, cream-top milk, and yogurt in an on-site inspected creamery. Beyond the farm store, it runs hands-on visits: cow cuddling, learn-to-milk sessions, self-guided tours, and a Dairy Discovery camp. The herd is raised without added hormones or antibiotics, and the store is open daily.
Our directory is built from many public sources across the internet and from farmers themselves. We work hard to keep listings accurate, but not every farm has confirmed its information with us. Farms marked Verified manage their own listing and have confirmed their details. Own a farm? Verify your listing →
Frequently Asked Questions
How many dairy farms & creameries are near Penn Yan?
US Farm Trail lists 4 dairy farms & creameries within about 30 miles of Penn Yan, New York, the closest being Crosswinds Farm & Creamery in Rock Stream. Every one sells direct to the public.
Can you visit dairy farms & creameries near Penn Yan in person?
Many welcome visitors — through a farm stand, on-farm store, or by appointment. Check each farm's page for hours and how to buy before you drive out.